quote Kotikkk :
Isn't good spanking a severe thing just by definition?
Only if you want it to be. "Good" has many meanings. If we're talking
punishment, or
cathartic spanking, then it could mean severe. But if we're talking about
erotic spanking, then it could have meanings along the lines of suitable, agreeable, competent, skillful, or certain to elicit a specified result. The primary arbiter here would be the subject, the spankee, since we're dealing with consensual activity.
The specific meaning will vary from person to person.
Furthermore, the meaning for the same person will vary depending on the mood, the perceived or expected purpose, the relationship to the spanker, etc.
An erotic spanking, starting gently and gradually increasing in intensity, may well result in a warm, red ass. The color might last an hour or two, or perhaps a day or two. In any case, it should be more than a gentle caress.
A hard erotic spanking, with the purpose of eliciting an endorphin rush, may well result in greater marking of the subject, including welts and bruises.
In any case, ten different people could have ten different meanings of what would be a "good" spanking to them.